Just before she started a new teaching job in Kensington, Maryland, Hannah Upp disappeared for a second time. The first time was 4 years earlier, days before her second year of teaching in New York City began. Somehow, Hannah emerged from both incidents virtually unscathed. She moved to St Thomas, in the Virgin Islands, to start another teaching job. Everything was going well until the island was hit by back to back hurricanes in September of 2017. When the storms passed, Hannah was gone again.